Quick Answer
Hummingbirds can and do use feeders without perches, but they generally prefer feeders with perches. Perches allow hummingbirds to rest while feeding, which conserves their energy. However, perchless feeders can still attract hummingbirds, especially if hung in an area with plenty of natural perching spots nearby. The key factors that attract hummingbirds are the nectar and the color of the feeder.
Do Hummingbirds Use Perchless Feeders?
Yes, hummingbirds will use perchless feeders. Hummingbirds have the unique ability to hover in place, allowing them to feed while their wings are in motion. So they do not require a perch in order to access the nectar in a feeder. However, hovering expends a lot of energy. Given the choice between a feeder with a perch and one without, hummingbirds generally prefer to be able to perch so they can rest while feeding. But a lack of perch will not deter them from visiting a feeder, especially if there are no other nectar sources available.
Here are some key points on hummingbird usage of perchless feeders:
– Perchless feeders can attract hummingbirds, especially if hung where there are natural perches like trees and shrubs nearby. The hummingbirds can use the natural perches to rest in between visits to the feeder.
– In the absence of adequate natural perching spots, hummingbirds may be less likely to frequent a perchless feeder. They will not want to expend the extra energy hovering nonstop.
– During migration when food is scarce, hummingbirds may be more likely to use perchless feeders even without nearby perches. When resources are limited, they are less choosy.
– In residential areas where feeders are abundant, hummingbirds may skip over perchless options in favor of feeders where they can perch and conserve energy while feeding.
– Perchless feeders can be useful in certain situations, like areas where larger birds are problematic. Lack of perch helps deter bigger birds.
So in summary, hummingbirds will use feeders without perches, but they prefer being able to perch while feeding. Lack of a perch is not a dealbreaker, but their feeder usage and loyalty tends to be higher when perches are present.
Advantages of Perch Feeders for Hummingbirds
Here are some of the main advantages perches provide hummingbirds at feeders:
– **Energy conservation** – Hovering expends a huge amount of energy for hummingbirds. Perches allow them to rest in between sips of nectar, conserving their energy. This is especially important during migration.
– **Feeding efficiency** – Hummingbirds (and other birds) swallow by tipping their head back. A perch allows a more natural feeding position to efficiently swallow nectar compared to hovering in place.
– **Comfort** – Hummingbirds seem to be more comfortable and content when they have a place to perch. Watching their behavior at feeders with and without perches shows they are more relaxed when able to sit.
– **Territoriality** – Adult male hummingbirds are territorial and use their perch to guard “their” feeder. The perch serves as a territorial marker.
– **Courtship** – Male hummingbirds perform aerial courtship displays for females from their perch base. The perch helps facilitate mating opportunities.
– **Longer feeding sessions** – When there is a perch available, hummingbirds tend to have longer, more sustained feeding sessions compared to “snacking” at perchless feeders in between flights.
– **More natural experience** – Feeders with perches better mimic how hummingbirds feed on flowers in nature since the birds are adapted to perch while feeding on blossoms.
So perches allow hummingbirds to feed more efficiently, comfortably, and naturally at artificial nectar feeders. This likely explains their strong preference for feeders with built-in perches in most situations.
Disadvantages of Perchless Feeders
While hummingbirds will use perchless feeders, here are some potential disadvantages:
– **Requires more energy** – Lack of perching spot means hummingbirds have to expend more energy hovering while feeding. This can be taxing, especially during migration.
– **Unnatural feeding position** – Hummingbirds have to tip their head far back to swallow which can be more challenging without a perch.
– **Limits duration of feeding** – Hummingbirds seem to “snack” at perchless feeders compared to longer sustained feeding on perch feeders.
– **Deters territorial behaviors** – Males cannot perch to guard the feeder without a perch. This may disrupt natural territorial displays.
– **No courtship perch** – Males have no base to perform aerial courtship dances to attract females. This could impact mating.
– **Increased aggression** – The extra energy expenditure of feeder hovering could make hummingbirds more aggressive and competitive at perchless feeders.
– **Less comfortable** – Hummingbirds appear less relaxed hovering in place compared to perching. Loss of comfort could deter usage.
– **Not as appealing** – When hummingbirds have a choice between a perched feeder and perchless option, they tend to favor the feeder with a perch.
So lack of a perch creates some unnatural challenges for hummingbirds around energy expenditure, feeding efficiency, comfort, and natural behaviors. But these drawbacks are not necessarily dealbreakers, as hummingbirds will still readily use feeders without perches in many cases.
Ideal Feeder Setup
The ideal hummingbird feeder setup consists of:
– At least one feeder with a built-in perch. This allows the hummingbirds to perch and rest while feeding.
– Multiple feeding ports on the perched feeder. This minimizes competition and allows multiple birds to feed at once.
– At least one additional perchless feeder, to provide extra feeding capacity.
– Positioning near natural perches like trees, shrubs, or a trellis. Gives birds alternate perching options.
– Adequate nectar volume to support the local hummingbird population and reduce competition.
– Nectar with proper sugar concentration (1 part sugar to 4 parts water, no food coloring).
– Feeders with a red color base (preferred color that attracts hummingbirds).
– Feeders cleaned/disinfected at least once per week to prevent mold and bacteria.
– Positioned out of reach of predators, and away from areas where larger birds congregate.
This type of setup provides the ideal combination of perched and perchless feeders to accommodate natural hummingbird feeding behaviors and energy needs. The addition of natural perches nearby further optimizes the feeding habitat for hummingbirds. Maintaining clean nectar, colors that attract hummingbirds, and adequate capacity for the population size further enhances the effectiveness of the setup.
Alternate Types of Perchless Feeders
While a basic hummingbird feeder without a perch is the most common type of perchless design, there are a few alternate styles:
– **Flying insect feeders** – These have a reservoir suspended from a wire or string. Hummingbirds access the nectar while hovering beneath the suspended reservoir.
– **Glass tube feeders** – A glass tube with access holes allows hummingbirds to insert their beak and feed while hovering around the tube.
– **Hanging cups** – Small cups filled with sugar water are hung from branches or hooks. Birds have to hover to drink.
– **Perch deterrents** – Some feeders have deterrents to prevent larger birds from perching while still allowing hummingbird access.
– **Suction feeders** – Feeders with suction cups allow hummingbirds to feed while temporarily attaching themselves via suction to a non-perch surface.
While more unconventional, these feeder designs all provide nectar access for hummingbirds without a traditional flat perch. The key is the lack of any stable horizontal surface for larger birds to perch. But these alternate feeders still work for hummingbirds in mid-hover.
Conclusion
Hummingbirds can and will use feeders without perches in many cases, so lack of a perch does not necessarily deter them as long as the nectar is adequately supplied. However, hummers strongly prefer to have a perching spot so they can periodically rest while feeding. Perches allow hummingbirds to feed for longer periods while conserving energy. Perches also facilitate natural behaviors like defending territories and displaying for mates. While perchless feeders have some applications in certain situations, feeders with built-in perches are generally the optimal design for attracting and sustaining hummingbirds. The ideal setup is to have multiple perched feeders supplemented by one or more perchless feeders. This configuration provides adequate feeding capacity for a diversity of hummingbirds and their behavioral preferences.
| Perch Feeders | Perchless Feeders |
|---|---|
|
|
Key Takeaways on Perches and Hummingbird Feeders
– Hummingbirds prefer feeders with perches but will use perchless feeders, especially if adequate natural perches are nearby.
– Perches allow hummingbirds to conserve energy while feeding. This is particularly important during migration.
– Feeders with perches better support territorial displays, courtship displays, and sustained feeding.
– Perchless feeders can supplement perched feeders to provide additional nectar access.
– Avoid relying just on perchless feeders, since hummingbird usage will be lower. Provide at least one feeder with a built-in perch.
– Ideal setup is multiple perched feeders supplemented by one or more perchless feeders.
– Simple nectar feeders without perches are the most common perchless design, but alternatives like flying insect feeders are used by hummingbirds.
– While perchless feeders work, hummingbirds clearly prefer being able to periodically rest on a perch while feeding. Perches make access easier and more energy efficient.
